No Big Deal if Your Logo is Similar to Another?
Is it really no big deal if your logo is similar to another company’s logo?
You might change your mind after reading this.
When Quark Inc. ditched it’s logo for a new one, several eyebrows were raised as there were quite a few other logos that looked very similar. Was it a giant conspiracy or mere coincidence? Do great minds really think alike? Unless we do a forensic-style research and investigation, we would not know which of these many designs came first and which, if any, “inspired” the others.
Nobody in serious business intentionally copies another’s corporate logo. That would be as good as commercial suicide, since legal suits will surely follow. Most me-too logos come about because people were impressed by the market leader’s logo or believe that it made sense to imitate the market leader as closely as possible. They were therefore inspired to adapt by tweaking and adjusting several components before they exclaimed “viola”. To have an original design can be challenging. It’s just like music. There are 12 notes to an octave and you might hit on the same tune with another music when you mix and match the notes. There’s “nothing new” under the sun.
To protect their intellectual property, some companies register trademarks. However, you can only file within your category. You simply cannot prevent another company calling themselves “Apple” or “Borders”. If all trademarks covered all uses, we would have run out of possible brand names and company names a long time ago.
Investing in a trademark does not guarantee a unique trademark. One famous example is from 1976 when NBC (National Broadcasting Company) released its new logo. That new logo cost a whopping USD600,000 to design. Even 30 years on, this amount is still down right awesome. The much-hyped about unveiling was soon over with a storm rising. Nebraska Educational Television Network pointed out that it had been using the same mono colour for many years. And, the design fee was a mere USD100. Since both companies were in the broadcast business, NBC had to reach a settlement with the Nebraska ETV Network. You would have thought that NBC would know all about it’s competitors but this is obviously not so.
Closer to home is the logo war between two famous bakkwa (barbecued sweetmeat) shops, Bee Cheng Hiang and Fragrance. In a half-page notice run in major dailies, Bee Cheng Hiang Hup Chong Foodstuff had placed its own logo, the Chinese character for “fragrant”, side by side with the logo of Fragrance Foodstuff which includes a stylistic representation of the same Chinese character. The notice sought to clarify that the two companies were unrelated. Fragrance then obtained summary judgment in the High Court (the second highest court in Singapore, from which appeals proceed to the highest, the Court of Appeal) against Bee Cheng Hiang for infringing the former’s copyright by using its logo, which was also a registered trade mark, without permission. The judge found that Bee Cheng Hiang’s notice subtly suggested that Fragrance’s bakkwa was inferior to its own. Also, the notice misled people into perceiving Bee Cheng Hiang had first use of the Chinese character “xiang”, and that Fragrance was a newbie to the bakkwa industry. This legal case simply point out that logo similarities would cause conflict between rivalry companies and confusion to customers.
So now what? Trademark does not provide total protection. Brand owners and designers cannot know in advance if the new or revamped logo resembles another’s. Paying top money to market research companies or designers may still earn you a legal suit. I honestly don’t have a clear answer on that. You can DIY your logo, buy a logo software or pay someone else to do it. Just think carefully what’s the story behind the logo and proceed with your logo design with all honesty, integrity and passion. At the end of the day, your conscience is clear even though you got an unwanted and undeserved law suit pending.
Source: CreativePro, Drew & Napier LLC
Check out these related posts:
Logo Have Sex? London Olympics 2012 Logo worth £400,000?
Alternative London Olympics 2012 Logo & Past Olympics Logo
Why is Logo Design That Important
How Much Should You Pay for a Logo Design
4 Great Tips to Hiring the Best Marketing/Advertising Agency
Or Get a Free Report on Successful Entrepreneurs
Free Report on Successful Entrepreneurs
Technorati Tags: logo, logo design, business logo, corporate logo, company logo, logo designer, brand, branding, why is logo important, marketing, advertising, new business, new logo
Popularity: 13% [?]
Stumble it!
June 6th, 2007 at 1:38 am
Hey Vivienne,
I don’t want a lawsuit to fight against.. That will really take up most of my capital and my precious time wasted which I could use it to earn money.
But it’s really a good idea to copy certain nice designs but please don’t over-do it.
I will still go all out for my own unique design though as I’m a rather graphic person.
Nice article!
Success,
Erwin
June 9th, 2007 at 2:35 pm
Wow! I can see that this could be a huge problem. Thanks for this insightful article.
I only designed a logo once, back when I was employed in a corporation. It was for a product and not a company. It was mostly the initials of the product in a particular font and color.
Thanks again!
June 10th, 2007 at 7:07 am
Erwin: Having your own identity is certainly better than merely modelling after another.
Laura: I’m sure commercial copywriting pose similar challenge too. I was at a seminar recently and even the facilitator said copy “modelling” is one quick way to success.
March 27th, 2008 at 2:53 pm
Thks. Good Info.